Perceptions toward wrongful convictions and needed reforms in the criminal justice system: Does working experience in law enforcement matter?

Authors

Natalia Ermasova, Governors State University
Aubrey Adams, Governors State University
Lisa Jackson, Governors State University

Abstract

"This study proposes to investigate how public views on the wrongful conviction issue are connected with the perceived need for criminal justice reform and whether the professional experience in law enforcement influences these perceptions. This study employs a qualitative research design, deriving its conclusions from the comparative analysis of the survey responses concerning the issue of wrongful convictions and the criminal justice system collected from 45 law enforcement professionals and 35 individuals without such experience. The comparative results reveal that for the respondents without working experience in law enforcement, racial/ethnical bias was one of the most substantial issues of wrongful convictions, while for the respondents with working experience in law enforcement, the main issue was connected to the harmful effect of such cases on the victims, their families, and society. The respondents from both groups believe that there is a need for criminal justice reform, particularly in several specific directions, including the justice system itself, legal defense, policing, investigation, diversity in the justice system, DNA technology, jury selection, training for law enforcement, prosecution, and defense attorney. However, there are notable differences between the groups in their ranking of the focus areas. The differences between the groups with different backgrounds and perspectives on the issue suggest that the development and implementation of the reform initiatives may require tailored approaches to address the specific concerns of each group."

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-No Derivative Works 4.0 International License.

Recommended Citation

Ermasova, Natalia; Adams, Aubrey; and Jackson, Lisa (2025) "Perceptions toward wrongful convictions and needed reforms in the criminal justice system: Does working experience in law enforcement matter?," Qualitative Criminology (QC): Vol. 14: No. 1, Article 2.
Available at: https://dc.swosu.edu/qc/vol14/iss1/2