Number 1 (2023):
Fall/Winter 2023, #143
Number 2 (2024):
#144, Spring/Summer 2024; special issue Fantasy Goes to Hell
Number 1 (2020):
Number 137, Fall 2020
Number 2 (2021):
(Number 138, Spring/Summer 2021; Ursula K. Le Guin Special Issue)
Number 1 (2019):
Special issue on Children's Mythopoeic Literature
Number 2 (2020):
Number 136, Spring 2020
Number 1 (2018):
Issue 133, Fall/Winter
Number 2 (2019):
Issue 134, Spring, 50th Anniversary Issue
Number 1 (2012):
Issue 119/120, Fall/Winter
Number 3 (2013):
Issue 121/122, Spring/Summer
Number 1 (2011):
Issue 115/116, Fall/Winter
Number 3 (2012):
Issue 117/118, Spring/Summer
Number 1 (2010):
Issue 111/112, Fall/Winter
Number 3 (2011):
Issue 113/114, Spring/Summer
Number 1 (2009):
Issue 107/108, Fall/Winter
Number 3 (2010):
Issue 109/110, Spring/Summer
Number 1 (2008):
Issue 103/104, Fall/Winter
Number 3 (2009):
Issue 105/106, Spring/Summer
Number 1 (2007):
Issue 99/100, Fall/Winter
Number 3 (2008):
Issue 101/102, Spring/Summer
Number 1 (2006):
Issue 95/96, Fall/Winter
Number 3 (2007):
Issue 97/98, Spring/Summer
Number 1 (1973):
Issue 9, Equivalent to Tolkien Journal 16
Number 2 (1975):
Issue 10, Equivalent to Tolkien Journal 17
Number 3 (1976):
Issue 11, Equivalent to Tolkien Journal 18
Number 4 (1976):
Issue 12, June
Number 1 (1970):
Issue 5, Equivalent to Tolkien Journal 12, Winter
Number 2 (1970):
Issue 6, Autumn
Number 3 (1971):
Issue 7, Winter
Number 4 (1972):
Issue 8, Winter